Recurring
Jay Reeves as Shawn Scott (season 1), a drug dealer and gang member who sometimes did good deeds, but was shot dead by rival gangs as part of revenge killing in front of his house after he paid Tyrone off to get out of the gang.
Spence Moore II as Chris Jackson (seasons 1–4; guest season 6), the quarterback of South Crenshaw High's football team. Despite initially resenting Spencer for moving to Beverly, he helped Beverly Eagles defeat Malibu using Crenshaw's old playbook.
Michelle Hayden as Ripley (season 1), a cheerleader for Malibu Charter School and love interest of Jordan, but she got him into trouble as she was a marijuana user.
Demetrius Shipp Jr. as Tyrone Moore (seasons 1–2), a gang leader in Crenshaw. He was the mastermind that killed both Brandon and Shawn Scott. He also put Preach into the hospital by shooting. He was apprehended by police on State Championship night after Coop set up a police ambush. However, he was released from jail after Preach decided not to testify. He was later killed on his front porch by Ruth Scott in revenge for killing her sons.
Brent Jennings as Willy Baker (season 1; guest seasons 3–7), Billy's father and Olivia and Jordan's grandfather. Former Beverly Hills Football coach that raised Billy to become an NFL player, he believed Billy abandoned him after going pro and leaving Crenshaw. He disapproved of his son's lifestyle and used to refuse to accept his daughter-in-law because she is white. Despite this, he received monthly payments from his son. He also conned money from his grandson by suggesting he could not afford medical care for his diabetes. In season 4, he suffered from a heart attack on prom night, which causes Billy and Laura to move into his house him to keep an eye on him. Becoming tired of their presence, he decided to move to Florida and stayed with his friend Jerome.
Casper Van Dien as Harold Adams (seasons 1–2; guest seasons 3, 5), Asher's father whom he tried to help after he recovered from his own alcoholism.
Mitchell Edwards as Cameron "Cam" Watkins (seasons 1–3; guest seasons 4–5), South Crenshaw's new receiver after Spencer left. Despite having great size, speed, and athleticism, he was often outplayed by Spencer as the cornerback due to his poor hands and easy tells. In season 3, he transferred to Westlake not wanting to play as a backup to Spencer.
Chad L. Coleman as Corey James (seasons 1–2), a former American football player-turned-coach and Spencer and Dillon's biological father, but he left his family after discovering Billy and Grace's affair. His football dreams were dashed after high school because he was stricken with life-threatening illness, which he later died of.
Kareem J. Grimes as Cordell "Preach" Simms (seasons 2–present; guest season 1), a gang member who initially followed Tyrone because he thought Tyrone saved Brandon's lives by serving two prison terms together. However, when Coop made him realize the Scotts were both killed by Tyrone, he tried to set a plan to kill him, but he failed, and was shot and critically injured, and was recovering in Intensive Care Unit post-operation. In season 2, he got a job as a security guard after he recovered and helped Coop gain an audience for her first show, but was arrested after Tyrone set him up and was sent back to prison for assaulting Buggs and breaking his parole violation. He was released in the season 3 premiere after Monique got his 1st strike conviction overturned. In season 4, he started working as an English Literature tutor for the football team at South Crenshaw High when Billy was an interim principal, but was arrested at the school for Monique's murder before the charges were dropped and got probation for unlawful possession of firearms due to "justifiable homicide". Despite this, Billy gave him another chance and let him continue to teach the students after seeing how well he connected with them.
Asjha Cooper as Kia Williams (seasons 2–3; guest seasons 1, 5–6), a South Crenshaw High student, Spencer's ex-girlfriend and an avid social activist. Her uncle, Flip Williams, is a reformed Bloods gang member.
Lahmard J. Tate as Flip Williams (season 2; guest seasons 1, 5), Kia's uncle and a reformed Blood gang member.
Jordan Belfi as Principal Ed London (seasons 2, 8; guest seasons 1, 4, 7), Beverly High's principal.
Elvis Nolasco (season 2; guest season 1) and Ray Campbell (season 4; guest seasons 3, 5–6) as JP Keating, Layla's father, a music mogul that grew up in Harlem, New York, and an alumnus of UCLA. He donated to build Rose Bowl's Locker Room. He was absent for most of Layla's childhood due to his job but he came back for good when he realized that Layla attempted suicide at the exact same place as her mother. He stepped back from his roles in his record label after meeting a new girlfriend.
Da'Vinchi as Darnell Hayes (seasons 2; guest seasons 3–7), new quarterback at South Crenshaw and the son of a woman whom Corey had a previous relationship with. He lived with Corey for 7 years in Nevada. While initially having a frosty relationship with Spencer, they reconciled in Corey's final days. He was invited to live with Grace soon after Corey died. He suddenly had to leave, because his birth mother was hurt while on military duty. He came back for a brief moment to convince Spencer not to give up football to save his community.
Corey Reynolds as Cliff Mosley (seasons 2, 8), the head of the Beverly High School Boosters until he was voted out as he tried to relinquish Billy Baker from his coaching role without his presence.
Kayla Smith as Rochelle Mosley (season 2), a recent graduate of Beverly Hills High School and aspiring sports journalist.
Geffri Maya as Simone Hicks (seasons 2–4; guest season 5), a Beverly High student who became pregnant, giving birth to a baby boy but deciding to give him up for adoption. She started a relationship with Jordan and the two even married during a trip to Las Vegas. However, the marriage was short lived as the two decided to get an annulment after realizing they were too young, but they continued dating. After graduating from Beverly High and reconciling with the foster family to retain visiting rights, she applied to go to Bringston University, a historically black college in Atlanta, at the request of her aunt, where she decided to revive her dream to become a professional tennis player, leading to the spinoff series All American: Homecoming.
Dina Meyer as Gwen Adams (season 2; guest seasons 3–4), Asher's mother who was once an escort and met Harold as one of her clients.
Lamon Archey as D'Angelo Carter (seasons 3–5; guest seasons 2, 6), the interim principal at South Crenshaw High, which he also attended in the past with Corey and Billy, but was sent to boarding school after his freshman year due to the bullying culture of the football team. He became Grace's husband at the beginning of season 5.
Erica Peeples as Monique "Mo" Moore (season 3; guest season 2), an attorney and Tyrone's older sister and Amina's mother. She shot Coop, then was killed by Preach for "justifiable homicide".
Anna Lore as Carrie (season 3; guest seasons 2, 4), Layla's friend but also a recovering alcoholic with serious attachment and abandonment issues. After Layla saved Carrie from jumping off a cliff while she was spiraling in season 3, Layla was traumatized and changed into a control freak in season 4. The two reunited in San Diego and she reassured Layla that she had moved back with her parents and finally found a stable job, which brought proper closure to what happened and their relationship.
Alexandra Barreto as Coach Elena Montes (seasons 3–4; guest seasons 5–6), new head coach for the Beverly High Eagles. Her husband is also a coach.
Alondra Delgado as Vanessa Montes (season 3), a new student at Beverly High School and the new head coach's daughter. She had a summer fling with Asher.
Noah Gray-Cabey as Frausto (seasons 3–4; guest season 5), a teammate of Spencer's from Crenshaw. He was unwelcoming to both Spencer and Coach Baker.
Simeon Daise as Jabari Long (seasons 3–6), an outside linebacker who was a teammate of Spencer's from South Crenshaw High and later became a student and football player at Coastal California.
Deric Augustine as Clay Taylor (seasons 4–5), a musician whom Layla had a summer fling with. He is the current CEO of 'Clay Taylor Entertainment', formerly 'Keating Records', which became a parent company to 'ForMonica Records'.
Mustafa Speaks as Coach Kenny Boone (seasons 4–6), wide receiver coach at Golden Angeles University who later became head coach.
Zachary S. Williams as Isaiah Winfield (season 4; guest season 5), a wide receiver who attended Golden Angeles University with Spencer, Jordan and Olivia.
Journey Montana as Jen (season 4), a girl with addiction issues for whom Olivia became sponsor.
Sean Carrigan as Ivan Garrett (seasons 4–5), the former head coach at Golden Angeles University before getting exposed by Olivia for illicit behaviours. He considered Isaiah to be his preferred wideout candidate for scholarship. As a head coach with a defensive background, he was also a very traditional fundamental coach with 46 as the base defense.
Miya Horcher as Jaymee Aquino (seasons 4–6), Asher's new girlfriend and baby mama. She was a waitress at Asher's stepfather's fine-dining restaurant, but had to take leave in the summer as she suffers from lupus. In season 5, after 3 months in remission, her symptoms returned on Billy Baker's birthday and she required hospitalization, which was the first time Asher saw her symptoms develop and worsen.
Christian James as Wade Waters (seasons 4, 6), former QB1 for the Golden Angeles University Condors, who after gaining NIL deals skipped practice, then lost his starting spot to Jordan. After being kicked out of the team, he was recruited by Coastal California in season 6.
Brittany Marie Batchelder as Davita Jones (season 4; guest seasons 5–6), a branding and marketing student and also a player for the women's soccer team at Golden Angeles University who helped Spencer build a social media presence and became friends with Olivia.
Kamar de los Reyes as Coach Montes (season 4; guest seasons 5–6), head coach at Coastal California College and the husband of Elena Montes.
Madison Shamoun as Skye (seasons 4–5), Coop's new love interest.
Alexis Fields as Denise Patterson (season 5; guest seasons 2–4, 6), a friend of Billy and Grace who is a South Crenshaw High School alum.
Ashley Argota Torres as Gia (season 5), Layla's assistant.
Pauline Dyer as Alicia (season 5), Spencer's new love interest.
Courtney Bandeko as Miko Scott (season 5), a fan of Patience with a lack of awareness of boundaries.
David Shatraw as Professor Richard Hill (season 5), Coop's law professor.
Jamel King as Coach Terence "Mac" McClelland (season 6), the offensive coordinator of the GAU football team.
Brian Borello as Ryan (season 6), Layla's business partner.
Melissa Jane Rodriguez as Charissa (season 6), a new roommate at the beach house.
Taiv Lee as Deion (season 6; guest season 7), a student at South Crenshaw who became friends with Spencer.
Gilbert Glenn Brown as Coach Bobby Shepard (season 7; guest season 6), the new football head coach of South Crenshaw High.
Elijah M. Cooper as Yasi Ray (season 7), the quarterback of South Crenshaw High.
Lauryn Hardy as Tori (seasons 7–8), a popular Beverly Hills High cheerleader who became friends and then got involved with KJ.
Terayle Hill as Marqui Edwards (season 7), Khalil's father who is a Crips gang member.
Sasha Lance as Breonna Strong (seasons 7–8), Coop's law professor and eventual girlfriend.
Brandon Spink as Grayson (season 7), KJ's teammate at Beverly High.
Angel Parker as Ava Jeremy (season 7), Cassius' wife and KJ's mother.
Sloane Avery as Elle Grant (season 7), a singer and songwriter whom Layla signed under her record label.
Briana Price as Tash Williams (season 8), Khalil’s estranged mother.
Victoria Noelle as Miranda (season 8), Khalil’s new love interest.