Derek Christopher Shepherd, often referred to as "McDreamy" for his attractiveness, was a fictional surgeon from the ABC medical drama Grey's Anatomy, portrayed by actor Patrick Dempsey. He made his first appearance in the series' pilot episode, "A Hard Day's Night", which was broadcast on March 27, 2005.
Derek was married to Addison Montgomery (Kate Walsh), but their relationship ended in divorce in 2007. Before his death in 2015, Derek was happily married to his longtime partner, Meredith Grey (Ellen Pompeo), with whom he had three children.
Derek served as the Chief of Surgery at Seattle Grace Mercy West Hospital (previously Seattle Grace Hospital, and later Grey Sloan Memorial Hospital). However, he abruptly resigned from the position in Season 7, following the traumatic hospital shooting.
For his portrayal of Derek Shepherd, Dempsey earned widespread recognition. He was nominated for the Golden Globe Award for Best Actor – Television Series Drama in both 2006 and 2007. Additionally, he also received a nomination for the Screen Actors Guild Award for Outstanding Performance by a Male Actor in a Drama Series.
Contents
Storylines
Derek arrives at Seattle Grace Hospital and comes as the new Head of Neurosurgery from New York City. He is a Bowdoin College graduate and attended Columbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons alongside his childhood best friend Mark Sloan and ex-wife Addison Montgomery and Private Practice characters Naomi Bennett and Sam Bennett. Derek was a student of Dr. Richard Webber and was enticed to come with an "offer he couldn't refuse" – the position of Chief of Surgery, which he eventually turned down. He specializes in highly complex tumors and conditions of the brain and spine, and came to Seattle Grace with a reputation for taking on "lost causes" and "impossible" cases that most of his peers would turn down. As an attending, he is both well-liked by patients and his scrub nurses for his compassion and polite bedside manner and feared by interns and residents who are intimidated by his reputation and high standards. He is passionate about his job and has been known to expel staff or remove students (or at least threaten them) from his service for being disrespectful about patients or if he deems their attitude to be detrimental to his patient's well-being.
Derek first meets Meredith Grey at a bar and has a one-night stand with her. He soon finds out that she is an intern at Seattle Grace. They begin to have feelings for one another, and it causes some awkwardness at work particularly after her supervising resident Dr. Miranda Bailey discovers their relationship. While most of his family members accepted Meredith, his sister, Nancy, particularly disliked her and repeatedly called her "the slutty intern"; as of season nine she still refuses to speak to Meredith or acknowledge her as her sister-in-law. His mother Carolyn approved as she felt Meredith's gray perspective of life complemented Derek's tendency to see everything in black and white.
Derek's background was generally a mystery for the first season and source of speculation amongst his colleagues due to his sudden departure from an established and highly respected practice in New York. In the season one finale, his past eventually catches up with him when his estranged wife Addison moves to Seattle and is offered a position by Dr. Webber. Shortly after that, his childhood best friend Mark joins Seattle Grace as the new head of plastic surgery. Derek and Addison attempt to repair their marriage but attempts were futile. Addison and Derek each began their practice in New York City, which placed a strain on their marriage. Their marriage was troubled in the years leading to Derek's decision to leave New York as it is eventually revealed in both Grey's Anatomy and Private Practice that Derek's mother did not approve of her (choosing to give her dead husband's ring to Derek's second wife, Meredith Grey) and Addison's brother Archer disliked Derek. Addison's affair with Derek's best friend Mark Sloan drove the wedge even further and Derek's departure to Seattle. Addison briefly attempted to have a relationship with Mark, which resulted in her becoming pregnant. She then had an abortion soon after she discovered that Mark cheated on her, and as she was still in love with Derek. She then moved to Seattle. In the season eight episode "If/Then", Meredith dreams of an alternate universe where her mother never had Alzheimer's; Derek and Addison are still married, but their strained relationship and Shepherd's disillusionment causes his career to stagnate, earning him the nicknames "Bad Shepherd" and "McDreary".
Development
Casting and creation
When Patrick Dempsey auditioned for the role of Derek Shepherd, he was initially afraid that he wouldn't land the part. However, Grey's Anatomy creator Shonda Rhimes was immediately convinced: "The very first time I met him, I was absolutely sure that he was my guy. Reading the lines of Derek Shepherd, Patrick had a vulnerable charm that I just fell for. And he had amazing chemistry with Ellen Pompeo." Rhimes later revealed that Dempsey's dyslexia initially caused some hesitation during the first table readings: "I did not know about Patrick's dyslexia in the beginning. I actually thought that he didn't like the scripts from the way he approached the readings. When I found out, I completely understood his hesitation. Now that we all know, if he is struggling with a word, the other actors are quick to step up and help him out. Everyone is very respectful."
Isaiah Washington, who eventually portrayed Preston Burke, also auditioned for the role of Derek Shepherd. Reflecting on the experience, Washington said his reaction to not getting the part was like "I'd been kicked in the stomach by 14 mules." Another actor considered for the role was Rob Lowe, who turned it down in favor of starring in the short-lived CBS medical drama Dr. Vegas. Some of Shepherd's medical cases on the show were based on real-life patients of Steve Giannotta, Chair of Neurological Surgery at the University of Southern California Keck School of Medicine, whom Rhimes consulted for inspiration.
In January 2014, Dempsey signed a two-year contract to stay on Grey's Anatomy, securing his presence through potential seasons 11 and 12. However, in April 2015, his character was unexpectedly killed off, even though his contract had not yet ended. Dempsey commented on his exit, saying, "It just evolved. It's just kind of happened. It was surprising that it unfolded, and it just naturally came to be, which was pretty good. I like the way it has all played out."
In August 2015, Rhimes commented: The decision to have the character die the way that he did was not a difficult one in the sense of what were the options? Either Derek was going to walk out on Meredith, and leave her high and dry, and what would that mean? That was going to suggest that the love was not true, the thing we had said for 11 years was a lie and McDreamy wasn't McDreamy. For me, that was untenable. Meredith and Derek's love had to remain Meredith and Derek's love. As painful as it was for me as a storyteller, because I had never really thought that was going to happen, it preserved what felt true to me, was that Derek was going to have to die in order for that love to remain honest. Because I really couldn't have the idea that he just turned out to be a bad guy who walked out on his wife and kids be a true story. To me, it felt like that was the only way to make Meredith and Derek's magic remain true and forever frozen in time.
Characterization
Rhimes described Derek Shepherd as the quintessential "Prince Charming". He was envisioned as a doctor who lives in his "own" universe, with little regard for the world around him, and exudes high sex appeal. Rhimes wanted him to be a man who was charming, devilishly handsome, and the type of guy every girl dreams of—a man who could also make wrong decisions, be perceived as a jerk, or be the ultimate heartbreaker. Rhimes intended for this character to be dynamic and easily adaptable to various storylines, knowing that viewers would fall in love with him despite his flaws.
Robert Bianco of USA Today noted the complexity of Derek's character, stating: "Derek could, at times, seem like two people, warm and funny one minute, cold and self-involved the next. Patrick Dempsey's gift was in making those two sides seem like part of the same person, while keeping us rooting for that person as a whole."
Reception
At the end of Season 2, Robert Bianco of USA Today suggested that Dempsey could be considered for an Emmy due to the "seemingly effortless way he humanizes Derek's 'dreamy' appeal with ego and vanity." However, Alan Sepinwall of The Star-Ledger was more critical of Derek in Season 3, particularly regarding his moral contradictions. Sepinwall wrote: "The attempt to give the moral high ground back to McDreamy was bad. Dude, whatever happened in New York ceased to count once you agreed to take Addison back. You're the one who cheated on her, and still you act like her getting back together with Mark justifies what you did?"
In Season 4, Debbie Chang of BuddyTV commented on Derek's immaturity, noting: "The only character who did not make me love him was Derek Shepherd. Yes, his love for Meredith torments him, but that does not give him the right to lash out at her when his clinical trial patients are dying. If things don't go absolutely the way he wants, then he refuses to cooperate. How immature can this man possibly be?"
Entertainment Weekly placed Derek in its list of the "30 Great TV Doctors and Nurses." He was also featured in Wetpaint's "10 Hottest Male Doctors on TV" and BuzzFeed's "16 Hottest Doctors On Television." His iconic relationship with Meredith Grey (Ellen Pompeo) was named one of TV Guide's "Best TV Couples of All Time."
Derek's friendship with Mark Sloan (Eric Dane) was also acclaimed, with Victor Balta of Today listing their bond in the "TV's Best Bromances." He described them as "the most exciting couple on Grey's," thanks to their "easy chemistry" and their ability to deliver "great comic relief" with their banter and wisdom. Their bromance was also included in various lists by About.com, BuddyTV, Cosmopolitan, Wetpaint. However, following the announcement of Dane's upcoming departure from the show, Mark Perigard of the Boston Herald disagreed, stating that Derek and Mark "never clicked like you'd expect friends would," calling their scenes together "uncomfortable" and "forced".