Say Hello to Sunshine and Finch EP (2003–2010)
While on tour, the band began working on writing new songs for their second album; several of these songs were debuted during live performances throughout 2003 and 2004. In November, they began working on demos with Mark Trombino. While in the process of writing these demos, Pappas left the band and went to join the duo JamisonParker as a touring drummer. Most of the songs that they recorded were written with Marc Allen, who at the time of recording, was the drummer of the band Counterfit. Other songs were recorded with Chris Tsagakis of RX Bandits, but none of those songs ended up being used on the second record. During the recording of the album, the band was moved between three different record labels: Drive-Thru Records and MCA Records, which was then purchased by Geffen Records. As a touring musician, Marc Allen played his first show with the band in January 2004. The band announced a tour on June 1st with Counterfit and Recover, which began in July and lasted until September. By the end of this tour, Counterfit disbanded and Mark Allen became Finch's full time drummer.
The band finished recording their sophomore album in January 2005. In May 2005, they released its lead single, "Bitemarks and Bloodstains", which they had debuted two years prior during the What Is It to Burn tour. The group's second album, Say Hello to Sunshine was released on June 7th, 2005. On the day of its release, they played an acoustic show at Tower Records, in Los Angeles, California. To promote the release, the band embarked on a European and North American tour from April through September. After this tour, the band toured as a supporting act for H.I.M, beginning on October 7th through November 24th. At the end of November, the band announced a hiatus, stating: "Amongst the many reasons for our decision, our individual priorities just lie in different places".
In October 2007, the group announced they would be reforming and planning a comeback tour. The band reformed with two new members, Andrew Marcogliese who replaced Marc Allen and Daniel Wonacott who replaced Derek Doherty, both of whom were bandmates of Barcalow's band Cosmonaut, which he started during the band's hiatus. Finch's comeback tour began on January 13th, 2008. On July 22, 2008, the band released a four-song EP titled Finch. The EP was the band's first record that was released independently. Finch spent most of 2008 touring in support of this release, including a summer headlining tour with Scary Kids Scaring Kids, Foxy Shazam and Tickle Me Pink. Finch announced in October 2008 that they had begun work on their third studio album and on May 30th 2009, they released a demo for the song "Hail to the Fire" on their Myspace page.
On December 17, 2010, after an extended period of inactivity and infrequent updates, Finch announced that they had broken up. They explained that each member had broadened his "musical pallet [sic]," which made it difficult for the band to collaborate on new music. On the same day, Finch released a digital single titled Epilogue that featured "Hail to the Fire" and "World of Violence", which were to appear on their third album.
In 2012, Nate Barcalow formed a new band called Earthbound Ghost.