2022–present: Career expansion
Johnson directed the 2022 biographical film BlackBerry, which dramatises the rise and fall of the BlackBerry line of mobile phones produced by Canadian tech company Research in Motion. Co-written by Johnson and Miller, it stars Glenn Howerton as Jim Balsillie, Jay Baruchel as Mike Lazaridis, and Johnson as Douglas Fregin. BlackBerry premiered in competition at the 73rd Berlin International Film Festival on February 17, 2023, and attracted widespread critical acclaim. The film won the Rogers Best Canadian Film Award from the Toronto Film Critics Association. It also became the most nominated film in the history of the Canadian Screen Awards, with 17 nominations, and won 14 awards including Best Motion Picture and Best Director, making it the most awarded title in the organisation's history. In 2024, Johnson served as jury president of the Compétition Cheval Noir at the 28th Fantasia International Film Festival.
Following the success of BlackBerry, Johnson and McCarrol received funding from Telefilm Canada to develop a feature film adaptation of Nirvanna the Band the Show—a project they had been workshopping as early as 2009. Nirvanna the Band the Show the Movie premiered on March 9, 2025 at South by Southwest. The film won critical acclaim and was nominated for the Rogers Best Canadian Film Award at the Toronto Film Critics Association Awards 2025. It earned eight nominations at the 14th Canadian Screen Awards, winning Best Motion Picture. Johnson won the Canadian Screen Award for Best Supporting Performance in a Comedy Film. Additionally, Johnson and McCarrol won Best Original Song for "The Alphabet Song". Johnson and McCarrol reprised their roles in Joel Haver's short film Nirvanna the Band Tries to Get an Animation Made.
After BlackBerry, Johnson was "inundated" with pitches for various biopics, including for a film focusing on celebrity chef Anthony Bourdain. Following a meeting with actor Dominic Sessa, Johnson and Miller conceived that the biopic would focus on Bourdain's early career. The film, titled Tony, released in August 2026. It is Johnson's first American film as well as his first feature that he does not star in. It received positive reviews. In July 2026, Johnson directed Tony actor Stavros Halkias' stand-up special, titled Uncle Stav. Filmed over four shows in Baltimore, the special is set to premiere on Netflix on September 8.
Johnson will direct a film based on the card game Magic: The Gathering, which he plans to make as the first part of a trilogy. He will also direct a film inspired by Slava Pastuk's 2010s cocaine smuggling operation, starring Finn Wolfhard and distributed by Neon. As early as 2023, he was developing a "TSA comedy" with Josh Safdie.