On Again-Off Again

Plot

William Hobbs and Claude Horton own a drug-manufacturing company and continuously bicker with each another. Their lawyer George Dilwig suggests a wrestling match between the two men, with the winner gaining full ownership of the company and the loser serving as the winner's butler for one year.

Cast

Bert Wheeler as William Hobbs

Robert Woolsey as Claude Horton

Marjorie Lord as Florence Cole

Patricia Wilder as Gertie Green

Esther Muir as Nettie Horton

Paul Harvey as Mr. Applegate

Russell Hicks as George Dilwig

George Meeker as Tony

Maxine Jennings as Miss Meeker

Kitty McHugh as Miss Parker

Hal K. Dawson as Sanford

Alec Harford as Slip Grogan

Pat Flaherty as Mr. Green

Production

The film is based on the 1914 play A Pair of Sixes by Edward Peple.

Robert Woolsey was suffering from kidney disease throughout production of the film and experienced constant pain.

Reception

In a contemporary review for The New York Times, critic Thomas M. Pryor wrote: "The new opus is no better and, perhaps, no worse than most of their previous excursions in the realm of low comedy. The boys are to be commended for their continued unabashed delivery of old gags."

Modern Screen’s Leo Townsend wrote that "those hardy perennials, Wheeler and Woolsey … [have] been handed a script that is slightly superior to the sort of thing they’ve been getting lately", and although some of "their gags are ancient … their slapstick is less broad and their sets look more expensive than usual, all of which makes their antics less painful than usual to those in the audience who aren’t wildly enthusiastic about them."

The Film Daily gave a more positive review, and wrote, "This will please the Wheeler and Woolsey fans and will ring up a healthy total of laughs. Edward F. Cline has done an excellent job of guiding the comedians in their various antics … Patricia Wilder, Esther Muir, Marjorie Lord, a winsome newcomer, Russell Hicks, Paul Harvey and George Meeker are among the principals who do good work."